Parmalat the fall of a dairy giantfinancecase study. This allowed parmalat to go public in italy and raise capital in the united states and other countries by selling shares and issuing bonds. Corporate governance failurescorporate governance corporate. The parmalat scandal remains on the biggest corporate scandals to have happened over the last 15 years. The founder of parmalat spa was sentenced to 18 years in jail for his role in the italian food giants 2003 collapse in europes biggest corporate bankruptcy. Many papers have already highlighted that the parmalat scandal was facilitated. Parmalat, a dairy company that is a household name in italy and is or was one of the countrys few international businesses, discovered that it. Factboxmain facts about collapse of italys parmalat.
Between those two fateful events, time would see the rise and fall of italys largest dairy company along with the football club that it bankrolled. The parmalat scandal parmalat is an italian company founded by calisto tanzi in 1961. Parmalats corporate governance structure failed to comply with some of the key existing italian corporate governance standards of best practice. However, italian corporate governance standards were not completely at fault in the parmalat case. Anyone who thought that an enronstyle fraud was unlikely to happen in europe has had a rude awakening with the erupting scandal at parmalat, the italian dairy company. This law enables insolvent companies to seize assets counterparts. Dec 30, 2003 tanzis parmalat empire has been wobbly for years. This article provides a case study on parmalat accounting scam. The sec travels to italy to assist italian officials in deciphering american involvement in the collapse of parmalat. The events leading up to the parmalat accounting scandal and ultimately the revelation of the accounting fraud and the reasons behind the scandal. I t started in a familyrun shop and ended with a lonely 17 years in prison.
Corporate governance, italy, parmalat, accounting fraud, code of best practice. Indeed, no other than the united states security exchange commission sec described the scandal as. Parmalat founder gets 10 years prison for market rigging. Now europe has a scandal as large as any uncovered in the united states. Parma and the parmalat scandal parma and the parmalat scandal 15012015 by kevin nolan 4. Parmalats corporate organization is based on the socalled italian conventional model, which consists of. Jan 16, 2004 the story behind parmalats bankruptcy by claudio celani. After purchasing its first agricultural business in brazil in the 1970s, parmalat grew at an unprecedented rate of more than 50% a year. Parmalat model of corporate governance a best practice in italy.
What were the events leading up to the parmalat accounting scandal and ultimately the revelation of the accounting fraud and the reasons behind the scandal. Parmalat is a huge and quite well known dairy product company in italy. Parmalat, europes enron of fraud, undermined european accounting and reporting standards. The period of the old parmalat which started in 1961 and ended in december 2003 with the outbreak of the financial scandal. Italian law enforcement arrested del soldato and 7 other executives for being involved in the largest accounting fraud in european history 1. Parmalat, in turn, has been sued by investors, banks, and other organizations. Parmalat fraud case study solution case study analysis. The business got its first real expansion break when italy, where the visible economy was about 75% stateowned until the early 1980s, began to. The company was named for parma the food valley in italian and lat an abbreviation of latte, italian for milk. Parmalat founder given 18year jail term over fraud bbc news. Jan 11, 2004 the scandal is also a fresh blow to the international accounting industry. Dec 09, 2010 the former chief executive of italian food conglomerate parmalat is sentenced to 18 years in prison for his role in a fraud scandal.
The history of parmalat can be divided into four main periods. When enron launched an era of scandal in 2002, old europe had a good sneer about the ugly excesses of american capitalism. Italybased dairy group parmalat spa and its french parent company, groupe lactalis sa, had their offices searched by italian tax police on tuesday, as part of a larger probe into the italian. At some point in time, it may well have been gigantic and stable, but in december 2003, shocking news was broken to parma, italy, and the world at large. The bankruptcy of the giant food company parmalat, warned italian finance minister giulio tremonti on dec. Parmalat finanziaria spa, an italian food giant started out as a family business specializing in dairy products. It is in charge of almost 50% of the dairy products in italy.
Parmalat accounting scandal summary the parmalat accounting. Parmalat finanziaria spa accounting scandal essay example. Investigators ignore role of banks and political leaders in parmalat scandal by chris sverige 11 february 2004 more than six weeks after the biggest corporate scandal of 2003 came to. Parmalat the fall of a dairy giantfinancecase studycase. Parmalat was founded in 1961 as a familyrun farm in northern italy. Parmalat is huge daily product company of italy, the eighth largest industrial group of the country. It later became clear that the groups debts were more than. Italy raids parmalat, lactalis in probe of us deal law360. The fraud, totaling nearly 18 billion euros, brought down the italian dairy giant and ruined investors across the globe.
The scandal is also a fresh blow to the international accounting industry. Parmalats auditor from 199099 was the italian branch of grant thornton international, one of the largest of the so. While bondi races against time to unearth the sources of the scandal, some corporate governance experts are already drawing lessons. The parmalat case coming shortly after the enron and wordcom scams, the parmalat scandal offers a good opportunity to. This paper analyse the current situation of the italian corporate governance and. Dec 18, 2008 the scandal broke when it emerged that almost 4bn of parmalat funds meant to be held in an account at bank of america did not exist. By the early noughties, parmalat has over 36,000 employees across the globe and controls a whopping 50 percent market share in its native italy. Parmalat s auditor from 199099 was the italian branch of grant thornton international, one of the largest of the so. Parma and the parmalat scandal these football times.
Starting from december 2003, parmalat and numerous other companies of the old group are admitted to the extraordinary administration procedures. Financial scandals and the role of private enforcement. The parmalat scandal the parmalat scandal parmalat is an. Such a enormous fraud, some would assume, would need to be highly complex and fully developed in plan as well as execution. Investigators ignore role of banks and political leaders in parmalat scandal by chris sverige 11 february 2004 more than six weeks after the biggest corporate scandal of 2003 came to light. Dec 31, 2003 anyone who thought that an enronstyle fraud was unlikely to happen in europe has had a rude awakening with the erupting scandal at parmalat, the italian dairy company.
At the time of its crisis in 2003, parmalat listed 214 subsidiaries in 48 different countries. Request pdf financial scandals and the role of private enforcement. Parmalat the fall of a dairy giant parmalat finanziaria spa, the case deals with the financial scandal at parmalat, one of the biggest companies in italy. Corporate governance, false accounting, parmalat, italy, europe, auditing, board of statutory auditors, audit committee, blockholder, code of best practice, fraud. Lyman 2004 have been labelling the parmalat case as a particularly italian scandal, suggesting that a case such as parmalat is countryspecific and more likely to happen in italy than elsewhere. Towards the end of 2003, it was revealed that the company had been resorting to fraudulent accounting. This is not surprising as italy is widely represented as a bad example also in the existing international. The former chief executive of italian food conglomerate parmalat is sentenced to 18 years in prison for his role in a fraud scandal. At some point in time, it may well have been gigantic and stable, but.
The parmalat scandal being touted as the biggest scandal in terms of value. Although it will be more than a year before those involved in one of the biggest cases of corporate fraud in european history are brought to trial, the impact of the parmalat scandal can be seen throughout the economic landscape. It was founded in 1961 by calisto tanzi, a 22 yearold college dropout and italian food industry heir. The biggest financial scandal in italy an example of worst practice of corporate governance gives rise to an analysis of the governance rules of the a. Abstract coming shortly after the enron and wordcom scams, the parmalat scandal offers a good opportunity to compare failures on both. Evolving from a small dairy shop into an international concern, parmalat appeared to be a gigantic and stable dairy producer. A comparative analysis of shareholder protections 26. The parmalat scandal evolving from a small dairy shop into an international concern, parmalat appeared to be a gigantic and stable dairy producer. Parmalat canada has operated in canada since 1997 and is a subsidiary of parmalat s. Aug 03, 2015 dozens of food service business were bought in europe, the united states, and south america so that by 1999. Tanzi and his family have become rich beyond their wildest dreams. A comparative analysis of shareholder protections in italy.
In the years that followed, the company grew into one of the largest dairy and food companies in italy and eventually became a multinational conglomerate. Italy was ripe for parmalat fraud the globe and mail. Parmalat is an italian worldwide leading diary company whose financial scandal. Parmalat case as a particularly italian scandal, suggesting that a case such as parmalat is countryspeci. Which was the role played in the story by auditors, consob and bank of. But this company does not only run in italy, but it is an international business, which is what makes the scandal a huge a. The scandal broke when it emerged that almost 4bn of parmalat funds meant to be held in an account at bank of america did not exist. Its main factory is located in collecchico near parma, northern italy. Dozens of food service business were bought in europe, the united states, and south america so that by 1999. The story behind parmalats bankruptcy by claudio celani. Request pdf corporate failure and the role of governance. Parmalat canada acquired these and other brands making it one of canadas largest food companies. Parmalat was among the largest foodbased companies in the world, and had a presence in a variety of product categories.
201 1521 1306 73 1311 273 177 711 370 1476 985 941 1056 1146 1334 310 685 752 1324 1 833 1075 778 638 892 1404 1547 1491 1185 288 160 894 904 668 1265 479 1499 479 608 1277